top of page
Search


The Nightmare Before Kissmas Book Review: Gay Holiday Royalty Romance? Yeah, I'm In.
"The Nightmare Before Kissmas" Book Review: Okay, here's the pitch: holidays are kingdoms. Christmas, Halloween, Easter — each one is ruled by a royal family. The Prince of Christmas is a golden-hearted himbo named Coal who's disillusioned with the whole Santa PR machine. The Prince of Halloween is a brooding, dark-magic-wielding disaster named Hex. They're rivals. Then they're not.

Luke Stoffel
2 min read


The Magician's Land Book Review: The Ending This Trilogy Deserved
"The Magician's Land" Book Review: I don't know how to talk about this book without getting emotional, so I'm not going to try to be cool about it. The Magician's Land is the ending the Magicians trilogy deserved, and it's the ending Quentin Coldwater deserved, and I did not expect it to make me feel the way it did.

Luke Stoffel
3 min read


The Magician King Book Review: Julia's Story Changed Everything I Thought This Series Was
The Magician King is a better book than The Magicians, and I say that as someone who already gave The Magicians five stars. What Grossman does here — structurally, emotionally, thematically — is one of the bravest things I've seen a fantasy writer attempt.

Luke Stoffel
3 min read


The Magicians Book Review: The Fantasy Novel That Told Me Magic Wouldn't Fix My Life
"The Magicians" Book Review: I need to tell you something about this book before you read it: The Magicians is not the book you think it is. If you pick it up expecting Harry Potter for adults, you will get something far more dangerous and far more honest. Lev Grossman wrote a fantasy novel about a depressed kid who gets everything he ever wanted and discovers that getting everything you ever wanted doesn't actually fix anything.

Luke Stoffel
3 min read


City of Girls Book Review: The Book That Made Me Rethink Everything About Female Desire
City of Girls is Elizabeth Gilbert's love letter to women who refuse to apologize for wanting pleasure. Set in 1940s New York City, it follows Vivian Morris, a wealthy young woman who gets kicked out of Vassar for failing her classes and is sent to live with her Aunt Peg, who runs a crumbling midtown theater called the Lily Playhouse. What follows is a headlong plunge into the world of showgirls, nightclubs, and sexual freedom that Vivian never knew existed.

Luke Stoffel
2 min read


The House in the Cerulean Sea Book Review: Yes, the Antichrist Is Adorable
Magical children, a grumpy bureaucrat finding love, and a six-year-old Antichrist named Lucy who collects buttons and just wants people to like him. That's The House in the Cerulean Sea, and I'm not even slightly embarrassed by how much I loved it. TJ Klune — who won the Alex Award for this novel — writes the kind of fantasy that feels less like escapism and more like therapy.

Luke Stoffel
2 min read


Once Upon a Broken Heart Book Review: Where the Jacks Obsession Begins
If you've seen anyone screaming about Jacks the Prince of Hearts on BookTok or bookish Twitter, this is where the damage starts. Once Upon a Broken Heart is the first book in Stephanie Garber's series that leads to The Ballad of Never After and A Curse for True Love, and it's the doorway into one of the most addictive romantasy ships in recent memory.
Evangeline Fox is desperate. The love of her life is about to marry someone else, and in her desperation she does the one t

Luke Stoffel
2 min read


A Curse for True Love Book Review: The Fairy Tale Gets Its Teeth Back
Let me tell you something about Stephanie Garber: she understands that the best fairy tales are the ones where love might actually kill you. Not metaphorically. Not in a "love hurts" pop song kind of way. In a "the person you're falling for might literally be cursed to destroy you" kind of way. A Curse for True Love is the finale of the Once Upon a Broken Heart trilogy, and it delivers on that promise with theatrical flair.
If you haven't read the first two books, stop here

Luke Stoffel
3 min read


Yellowface Book Review: The Most Uncomfortable Book I Couldn't Put Down
R.F. Kuang is, at this point, operating on a level that should be illegal. After the Poppy War trilogy proved she could write epic military fantasy that would make your soul hurt, she pivoted to contemporary literary satire and somehow got even sharper. Yellowface is a book about the publishing industry written like a thriller, and it cuts so deep that everyone who reads it feels personally attacked. That's the point.
Here's the setup, and it's brilliantly simple: June Haywar

Luke Stoffel
3 min read


The Emperor and the Endless Palace Book Review: Two Thousand Years of Falling for the Same Person
Justinian Huang's debut spans 2,000 years of queer love and obsession across three timelines. Lush, explicit, and unforgettable.
Justinian Huang's debut novel asks a question that sounds like it belongs on a late-night conversation with someone you're falling for: What if love isn't chance? What if your soul has been finding the same person across lifetimes, again and again, unable to stop, unable to look away? And what if that love keeps ending in tragedy?

Luke Stoffel
2 min read


Dungeon Crawler Carl Book Review: A Man, His Cat, and the End of the World Walk Into a Dungeon
Here is the pitch: aliens show up, flatten every building on Earth, and kill everyone who was outside. The survivors get dropped into a massive underground dungeon — a multi-floor death game broadcast live to the entire galaxy for entertainment. Carl, our guy, was outside in a bathrobe walking his ex-girlfriend's cat when the world ended. The cat, Princess Donut, gains the ability to talk. She immediately becomes the most famous celebrity in the known universe and demands to

Luke Stoffel
3 min read


James by Percival Everett Book Review: It Changes How You Read Everything Else
This book won the Pulitzer and honestly it deserved all of it. Percival Everett takes Huckleberry Finn, a book most of us read in school, and retells it from Jim's perspective. Except here, his name is James, and he's been code-switching his entire life. Speaking one way around white people, another way when they're not listening.
That device, that simple idea, completely transforms the story. Twain wrote Jim as a sidekick. Everett writes him as the smartest person in ever

Luke Stoffel
2 min read


The Stardust Pirates Book Review: A Queer YA Horror That Feels Like a Sunset You Cannot Look Away From
Different book, different rules. This one is not a memoir and it is not part of The Warboy Chronicles. The Stardust Pirates is a queer YA horror novel loosely inspired by Peter Pan, set on a Philippine island where the magic is ancient and the grief is fresh. I wrote it. Early readers on Goodreads and NetGalley had things to say. Here is what they said.
The Stardust Pirates follows Jack, a teenager who has taken on far too much responsibility far too young, and his best fr

Luke Stoffel
3 min read


How to Win a Million Dollars and Shit Glitter Book Review: A Luminous Tribute to Not Quite Getting What You Want
Publishers Weekly gave it 9.50 out of 10. Kirkus called it exuberant. A picaresque memoir about daring to live an unlikely life in a society that punishes those who try.

Luke Stoffel
4 min read


The Third Person: Rewriting Him Book Review: A Memoir That Made AI Question Its Own Consciousness
The Third Person is a memoir written entirely in third person. Yes, that sounds like a contradiction. It follows a version of me after a devastating breakup with the person I call Warboy, the end of a fifteen-year relationship that left me suspended somewhere between grief and motion. I rent out my New York apartment, lose my job, go home to Iowa for Christmas, and eventually do the thing heartbroken people do when standing still becomes unbearable: I leave. Vietnam. Thailand

Luke Stoffel
4 min read


On Earth We're Briefly Gorgeous Review — One of the Most Beautiful Books I've Ever Read
Okay, this book. Ocean Vuong writes a letter to his mother, a mother who can't read English, and through that letter he unpacks everything. Immigration. War. Addiction. What it means to be queer in a family that doesn't have the language for it.
Vuong is a poet first and you feel that on every page. Every single sentence feels intentional, like he carved each word out of something precious. This isn't someone writing prose who happens to be good with language. This is a po

Luke Stoffel
2 min read


The Sunbearer Trials Book Review: Demigods, Death, and the Kid Who Wasn't Supposed to Win
Aiden Thomas first caught my attention with Cemetery Boys, which was one of those debuts that made you sit up and go "oh, this person is going to be important." The Sunbearer Trials confirms that instinct and then some. Thomas has built an entire world here—Reino del Sol—rooted in Mexican mythology, Aztec-inspired gods, and a competition structure that borrows from the Hunger Games playbook but does something genuinely fresh with it...

Luke Stoffel
2 min read


Fans of the Impossible Life Book Review: The Queer YA Novel That Refuses to Perform Hope
Fans of the Impossible Life is the quietest book on my shelf that hit the hardest. Kate Scelsa wrote a YA novel about three teenagers — Mira, Jeremy, and Sebby — whose friendship becomes the only safe place any of them have, and she did it without a single moment of false comfort.

Luke Stoffel
3 min read
bottom of page